• Type:
  • Genre:
  • Duration:
  • Average Rating:

Roger Kanno

Review: Prehistoric Planet

Prehistoric Planet (2022)

review | Prehistoric Planet

This Planet Earth-like documentary series uses stunning CGI to bring the world of the dinosaurs to life

by Roger Kanno
May 28, 2022

Apple TV+’s latest big-budget spectacle is Prehistoric Planet, a five-part nature documentary that debuted May 23 with a new episode available each day through May 27. With executive producers Jon Favreau and Mike Gunton attached to this BBC Studios Natural History Unit project, Sir David Attenborough providing narration, and Hans Zimmer, along with Kara Talve and Anže Rozman, composing the score, it doesn’t lack for high-powered creative talent to help it create buzz. Apple even hosted live premiere events at IMAX theaters in Los Angeles and London preceding the streaming release of the series, which they claim “will transport viewers 66 million years into the past to discover our world—and the dinosaurs that roamed it . . . in an epic week-long event.” 

State-of-the-art CGI provides a glimpse into the world of dinosaurs in this BBC Planet Earth-like series. While I’m not sure I would characterize it as an epic week-long event, it is extremely well made, will appeal to those who enjoy natural-history documentaries, and is especially family-friendly. Each episode is based on a particular habitat, with titles such as “Coasts” or “Deserts,” and tells humanizing stories about the different species of dinosaurs that inhabit them and their struggles to survive. The narrative is engaging and the information presented is said to be based on paleontological evidence, with the series managing to both educate as well as entertain. 

The main reason to watch Prehistoric Planet is to see the photorealistic renderings of the dinosaurs. The CGI was created by the Moving Picture Company, which has worked on myriad other projects including collaborating with Favreau on The Jungle Book and The Lion King, winning Visual Effects Oscars for both. The DolbyVision HDR presentation is absolutely breathtaking at times. The manner in which light reflects off the scaly skin of the creatures in closeups is stunningly realistic. There are also dinosaurs with fur or feathers with similarly fine levels of detail present. Colors are not over-the-top saturated and are actually a little muted; even so, they look very natural even though the visuals may be computer generated. Not all of the shots in Prehistoric Planet are CGI but the animation is so lifelike it’s difficult to tell where the occasional live-action shots have been incorporated.

The camera angles change within scenes, and background and foreground objects move in and out of focus, providing a more realistic viewpoint of this artificially created world. The motion of the creatures is also incredibly smooth and natural. As gigantic Dreadnoughtus males clash in a display for mates, the movement in their legs and long necks looked exactly how I would imagine such enormous creatures to move. Every rippling muscle under their leathery skin and the unified motion of their entire bodies as they methodically shift their massive weight was perfectly captured. One of the few times my disbelief wasn’t totally suspended was during an underwater scene where the rapid swimming motions of a predatory Kaikaifilu looked a little too choppy. Otherwise, I was constantly in awe of the spectacular visuals. 

While the visual presentation is nearly flawless, the Dolby Atmos soundtrack is not as stellar. This is a nature documentary so I didn’t really expect massive, room-crushing T-Rex foot stomps, but a bit more volume and drama at times would have been welcome. The surround and height channels are used sparingly, such as during underwater scenes, to provide a subtle sense of envelopment. However, in forest scenes or even shots taking place in caves, there is little sense of surround ambience, with much of the sound anchored to the front channels. The music score is well-recorded but is presented at fairly moderate levels with very few rousing crescendos to enhance the onscreen action. 

If you’re looking for heart-pounding, Jurassic Park-like thrills, you’ll have to look somewhere else. However, the five episodes of Prehistoric Planet do manage to deliver quality, family-oriented entertainment with fantastic visuals. 

Roger Kanno began his life-long interest in home cinema almost three decades ago with a collection of LaserDiscs and a Dolby Surround Pro Logic system. Since then, he has seen a lot of movies in his home theater but has an equal fascination with high-end stereo music systems. Roger writes for both Sound & Vision and the SoundStage! Network.

PICTURE | The DolbyVision HDR presentation is absolutely breathtaking at times, with colors looking very natural even when the visuals are computer generated 

SOUND | The Dolby Atmos soundtrack doesn’t rise to the level of the visuals. You don’t expect room-crushing T-Rex foot stomps in a nature documentary but a bit more volume and drama would have been welcome.

© 2025 Cineluxe LLC

Review: Operation Mincemeat

review | Operation Mincemeat

A young Ian Fleming is a key character is this well-done Netflix presentation of a real-life WWII spy tale

by Roger Kanno
May 16, 2022

Operation Mincemeat is a gripping historical drama based on the book of the same name by Ben Macintyre. It recounts the tale of a World War II British spy mission to deceive German forces into believing an Allied invasion would occur on the shores of Greece to conceal an actual landing planned for Sicily. The covert plan was based on an idea contained in the top-secret “Trout Memo,” reportedly written by British naval intelligence officer Ian Fleming. Yes, that Ian Fleming, the one who later went on to write the James Bond novels and whose character plays a supporting role in the film and provides the narration. The film premiered at the British Film Festival in Australia in November 2021, was released in the UK on April 15, 2022, and began streaming on Netflix on May 11.

Lieutenant Commander Ewen Montagu (Colin Firth) and Flight Lieutenant Charles Cholmondeley (Matthew Macfadyen) develop a plan to plant false papers on a corpse disguised as a fictitious British airman, Major William Martin, in the hopes German intelligence will intercept the fake documents. To make the deception more believable, Montagu, Cholmondeley, and their team create an entire false identity for Martin. Watching the meticulous process of developing that fabricated identity is both fascinating and revealing of the characters and of the team’s dynamic.

Firth and Macfadyen are excellent as the leaders of the team, but Kelly Macdonald and Penelope Wilton flesh out the storyline as Jean Leslie and Hester Legget respectively, the women recruited to provide support to the team. Both Macdonald and Wilton manage to steal many scenes as they reveal the strength of their characters and their importance to the development of the operation. The direction by John Madden (Shakespeare In Love, Best Exotic Marigold Hotel) is solid, although a few plot elements, such as romantic tensions between the team members, seem slightly forced at times. Otherwise, he keeps the story flowing at a good pace and there was enough suspense and tension to keep me absorbed in the film without overwhelming me. 

The film was shot in ArriRaw at 4.5K and mastered in 4K, and the DolbyVision presentation on Netflix has a pleasingly natural appearance. Scenes involving a submarine during a nighttime storm were challenging, but the breaking waves and driving rain looked crisp and well-defined even in the low light. Another particularly demanding scene has Montagu walking through pitch darkness with a lantern illuminating a circle of light around him. The picture remained solid and finely detailed as the nature of the light changed when it was reflected off the uneven ground, creating rapidily changing shadows. 

Interior shots often exhibit a sepia tone, providing a vintage look appropriate to the film’s setting of nearly a century ago. When the scenes shift to outdoors, the picture takes on a slightly cool, bluish hue. In a garden scene where intelligence officers, including Fleming, meet with Prime Minister Churchill, the collars of their crisply pressed white shirts are bathed in the pale blue light. This lighting gave their black wool coats and felt hats a slightly lighter hue, but there was exquisite detail in the stitching and fibers of the materials. 

From the opening suspenseful music mixed with thunderously crashing waves and howling wind, the sound design of Operation Mincemeat is engaging and active even though it’s presented in standard 5.1 audio. The stark clacking of typewriter keys is used as an effective device to introduce scenes, along with the dry, matter-of-fact delivery of the narration by actor/musician Johnny Flynn who plays Fleming. The score is atmospheric and involving, but music is also used to punctuate the onscreen action as when Montagu and his team visit a Soho club and the jazzy tones of a saxophone and a moody piano fill the air. A big band plays later in the scene and is limited primarily to the front speakers, but the sounds of indistinct conversations emanate subtly from the surrounds, creating an effective sense of envelopment.

I was pleasantly surprised by Operation Mincemeat. The picture and sound aren’t quite reference quality but they are still very good, and combined with the film’s compelling narrative, make this one of Netflix’s better recent releases.  

Roger Kanno began his life-long interest in home cinema almost three decades ago with a collection of LaserDiscs and a Dolby Surround Pro Logic system. Since then, he has seen a lot of movies in his home theater but has an equal fascination with high-end stereo music systems. Roger writes for both Sound & Vision and the SoundStage! Network.

PICTURE | The DolbyVision presentation on Netflix has a pleasingly natural appearance, even if it isn’t quite reference-quality

SOUND | The sound design is engaging and active even though it’s presented in standard 5.1 audio

© 2025 Cineluxe LLC

Review: Pachinko

Pachinko (2022)

review | Pachinko

This dramatic series about four generations of a Korean family gets off to a strong start on Apple TV+ 

by Roger Kanno
April 18, 2022

Based on the novel of the same name by Min Jin Lee, Pachinko is a limited-run series on Apple TV+. It began streaming on March 25 with three initial episodes and with additional installments dropping weekly for a total of eight episodes. Spanning four generations, it tells the tale of a Korean woman, Kim Sunja, who grows up in Japanese-occupied Korea and later moves to Osaka where her son finds success as a pachinko-parlor operator, and of her grandson, Solomon, who becomes an Ivy League-educated investment banker based in New York. 

As with many Apple TV+ projects, Pachinko benefits from high production values, and the series starts off strongly with a great visual style and an engaging audio presentation. Early in the first episode, a very young Sunja and her father chase dragonflies through a beautiful meadow bathed in early morning sunlight. The reflections of light off the tall grass and Sunja’s perfectly smooth complexion contrasted by her long, jet-black hair and with her father’s darker, rougher complexion are all captured perfectly in Dolby Vision HDR and backed by the lilting strings and playful piano of Nico Muhly’s gorgeous orchestral score mirroring the pastoral scenes.

The colors are slightly cool and on the pale side, but the lighting is sumptuously natural, with just a touch of softness that’s film-like and pleasing, especially when compared to the ultra high contrast and oversaturated colors of many video productions these days. This bucolic setting transitions to the infectiously catchy opening credits featuring the ’60s Grass Roots hit “Let’s Live for Today” as the main characters dance joyously in slow motion against the tacky backdrop of a pachinko parlor. The scene then shifts to a jetliner touching down with some serious bass as the wonderfully mixed “Road to Nowhere” by the Talking Heads fills the front soundstage as Solomon returns to Osaka. There he visits his father at the pachinko parlor, where the sounds of clinking metal balls and chatty patrons emanate distinctly from all channels.

Pachinko is a serious drama with serious themes and is often dialogue-centric, so not every scene is filled with such auditory complexity, but the sound design can be extremely creative. This artistry is mirrored in the cinematography, where something as mundane as cooking rice takes on a deeper and more poetic meaning as the camera lovingly lingers over the grains of rice as they’re carefully washed, the cloudy water is rinsed away, and the pot is readied for steaming as Mulhy’s score effectively accompanies the onscreen action, but this time incorporating a beautifully mournful choral lament. 

As beautiful as Pachinko is to look at, and as immersive as the audio can be, the narrative is equally as engaging. It’s a complex story about colonialism, family values, and relationships spanning many generations, told mostly through the eyes of Sunja, played by Academy Award winner Youn Yuh-jung, as she reflects on her life through a series of flashbacks. 

Youn once again stands out amongst a strong cast as she did in Minari, proving that her Oscar or the many other accolades she has received were not a one-off. The other actors are also all excellent, with wonderfully nuanced performances that bring the absorbing adapted screenplay to life. Then there’s the manner in which the dialogue switches between the Korean and Japanese languages that is both telling and symbolic as the characters face prejudice and intolerance even as they find success away from their homeland. And if you don’t recognize the difference between the Korean and Japanese dialogue, the subtitles are colored-coded to indicate which language is being spoken. 

The novel is split into three time periods, with the TV adaptation moving back and forth between the eras, which isn’t faithful to the original story but works in the television medium. It remains to be seen how much of the novel’s plot will be uncovered by the end of the eighth and final episode of the first season of Pachinko. However, the show is reportedly intended to run for four seasons to tell the entire story of the multiple generations of characters, even though plans have yet to be released for additional seasons. Judging by the quality of what I have seen thus far, I sincerely hope Apple TV+ decides to renew Pachinko.  

Roger Kanno began his life-long interest in home cinema almost three decades ago with a collection of LaserDiscs and a Dolby Surround Pro Logic system. Since then, he has seen a lot of movies in his home theater but has an equal fascination with high-end stereo music systems. Roger writes for both Sound & Vision and the SoundStage! Network.

PICTURE | The series’ look is film-like and pleasing, especially when compared to the ultra high contrast and oversaturated colors of many recent video productions

SOUND | Since this is a dialogue-centric drama, not every scene is filled with auditory complexity, but the Atmos mix is often extremely creative

© 2025 Cineluxe LLC

Review: The Adam Project

The Adam Project (2022)

review | The Adam Project

This latest Ryan Reynolds/Shawn Levy collaboration might not be Free Guy but it makes for a family-friendly action comedy

by Roger Kanno
March 23, 2022

Netflix’ latest big-budget feature, The Adam Project, is brought to you by director Shawn Levy and star Ryan Reynolds, the same people who created Free Guy. In this family-friendly action-comedy, Reynolds plays Adam Reed, who travels back in time to save his wife and fellow time pilot while enlisting the help of his childhood self along the way. It’s not of the same caliber as Back to the Future—no time-travel film has yet come close to equaling that Robert Zemeckis classic—nor is it as much fun as Free Guy, but Reynolds is his usual engaging self and Levy’s direction and the overall production is polished and proficient.  

The fast-talking, almost constant banter from Reynolds can become a bit much at times, but there are plenty of exhilarating action scenes to keep the film moving along at a nice clip. And although it is mostly family-friendly, it’s rated PG-13, so there is some cursing and it does get more serious and a little sentimental part way through. There is excellent support from Mark Ruffalo and Jennifer Garner as Adam’s parents. They don’t capture the chemistry they had in 13 Going on 30, but they too are their usual appealing selves. Netflix has produced some excellent dramas recently—The Irishman, Uncut Gems, and Roma among others come to mind—but their blockbuster action films have not yet been able to equal the success of those dramas. Nonetheless, The Adam Project is an amusing diversion even if it fails to break any new ground. 

Contributing to the enjoyment is how wonderful it looks on a high-quality display. There are a few instances where the Dolby Vision picture streamed from Netflix broke up slightly, such as scenes with explosions and a lot of smoke and fire filling the screen, but these were infrequent. Much of the film takes place during overcast days or at night, but the lighting always remained consistent and natural with extremely dark black shadows and excellent HDR details. For instance, as the young Adam walks through a forest at night, objects directly in the beam of his flashlight are perfectly illuminated, while reflected light reveals a lot of detail in faces and background objects. So while the scene is very dark overall, there are still plenty of visual cues such as the dampness of the glistening undergrowth. Then when he stumbles upon the time jet’s crash site, the glowing embers gently falling from the tree tops really pop against the dimly lit, starry sky.  

Many of the scenes exhibit a stylized blue-green tinge, and the picture has a somewhat soft character, giving the movie an almost film-like quality as opposed to the hyper-detailed look of a lot of films shot on digital. While the lighting is extremely natural and captures the languid beauty of cloudy skies and misty outdoor locations shot in the Pacific Northwest, the CGI time-jet scenes can be a little over the top and look cartoonish, although that suits the light-hearted nature of the film.

The sound design is also first-rate and presented in a satisfying and enveloping manner in Dolby Atmos with aggressively mixed action sequences often accompanied by great classic rock songs. This movie might not elicit the urge to create a mixtape as with Guardians of the Galaxy and its memorable soundtrack, but I couldn’t help but bob my head and tap my toes as Steve Winwood belted out the vocals from “Gimme Some Lovin’” during the time-jet dogfighting scenes. The final fight scene features hand-to-hand combat choreographed to Boston’s “Foreplay/Long Time” and judicious use of the surround and height channels, so the constant action is all around with some very deep bass effects to make your audio system really rumble. 

I’m really looking forward to the more adult, upcoming R-rated collaboration between Levy and Reynolds in Deadpool 3. In the meantime, the extremely active Dolby Atmos surround mix and excellent visuals delivered in Dolby Vision, help make The Adam Project an entertaining movie to enjoy with the family.  

Roger Kanno began his life-long interest in home cinema almost three decades ago with a collection of LaserDiscs and a Dolby Surround Pro Logic system. Since then, he has seen a lot of movies in his home theater but has an equal fascination with high-end stereo music systems. Roger writes for both Sound & Vision and the SoundStage! Network.

PICTURE | The Dolby Vision image looks wonderful, with extremely black shadows and excellent HDR details, although scenes with smoke and fire can cause it to break up slightly

SOUND | The Atmos mix presents the first-rate sound design in a satisfying and enveloping manner, with aggressively mixed action sequences often accompanied by great classic rock songs

© 2025 Cineluxe LLC

Review: The Lost Daughter

The Lost Daughter (2021)

review | The Lost Daughter

Maggie Gyllenhaal’s directorial debut may be uncomfortable to watch, both emotionally & visually, but proves worth the investment

by Roger Kanno
March 14, 2022

Maggie Gyllenhaal is known for taking chances as an actor. She has portrayed diverse characters in a variety of genres from blockbusters like The Dark Knight to art-house films such as Secretary and the critically acclaimed Crazy Heart. And she continues to take chances, but this time as a first-time director and the screenwriter of The Lost Daughter, based on the novel of the same name by Elena Ferrante. This unnerving psychological drama stars Olivia Coleman as Leda, a literature professor on holiday in Greece who develops a strange fascination with a young mother, Nina (Dakota Johnson) and her daughter, Elena (Athena Martin). And in a series of flashbacks, we see how the young Leda, played by Jessie Buckley, struggled in raising her two daughters and how observing Nina interacting with Elena stirs up painful memories.

Scenes with the young Leda and her daughters are often difficult to watch as she wrestles to reconcile her yearnings for freedom with the love she feels for them. Buckley is certainly deserving of her Oscar nomination for this film, but previous Oscar-winner Coleman, who is again nominated for her portrayal of Leda, is uncannily convincing as the socially awkward and tormented mother. You can feel the discomfort seething below her character’s surface as she reacts to the actions of others with a mild look of disdain or scorn that masks a much deeper, psychological pain. There are other fine performances including a memorably poignant turn by Ed Harris as the caretaker of the vacation property who tries to befriend Leda and Peter Sarsgaard, Gyllenhaal’s real-life husband who plays a highly regarded literary colleague from Leda’s past.

Fellow Cineluxe reviewer Dennis Burger lamented that the loving cinematography of Paul Thomas Anderson’s Licorice Pizza, which was shot on 35mm film, suffers from a lackluster 1080p SDR video presentation and deserves 4K UHD treatment. The Lost Daughter’s cinematography is much less complex as is understandable for an independent film with a modest budget. The standard HD picture quality on Netflix was more than adequate for the uncluttered and straightforward cinematography, even though at times I wished for a bolder visual statement. 

What can be disconcerting is the handheld camera work and many closeups with short depth of field. This often results in only foreground objects or backgrounds being in focus with an unsteady framing that can be visually distracting, especially on a large screen. The closeups of faces are simultaneously intimate and uncomfortable to watch, but do provide a window into the emotions of the characters, including the deeply buried feelings that haunt Leda. So while the shaky, slightly claustrophobic picture may be at times distracting, it is crucial to the narrative and our understanding of the characters.

The 5.1-channel audio presentation is also quite serviceable, although only the front three channels remained active throughout most of the film. For instance, during a party scene, Bon Jovi’s “Livin’ on a Prayer” plays almost entirely from the front channels with very little music emanating from the surrounds. There were also no ambient sounds of conversations or clinking of cutlery and dishes, which would have enhanced the auditory experience. Nonetheless, dialogue was always intelligible and I had no difficulty in following the storyline as it unraveled the complicated relationships between the characters through their conversations.

Olivia Coleman’s masterful performance as Leda will stay with me for a long time, but much of this film’s impact can also be attributed to the supporting performances and Maggie Gyllenhaal’s talented direction and screenplay. It may be unsettling to watch at times, but The Lost Daughter reminds us of just how complex and fractured family relationships can be and is well worth seeking out.

Roger Kanno began his life-long interest in home cinema almost three decades ago with a collection of LaserDiscs and a Dolby Surround Pro Logic system. Since then, he has seen a lot of movies in his home theater but has an equal fascination with high-end stereo music systems. Roger writes for both Sound & Vision and the SoundStage! Network.

PICTURE | The standard HD picture quality is more than adequate for the uncluttered and straightforward cinematography

SOUND | The 5.1-channel audio presentation is also quite serviceable, although only the front three channels remain active throughout most of the film

© 2025 Cineluxe LLC

Review: The King’s Man

The King's Man (2021)

review | The King’s Man

This roots-of-the-Kingsman story is less breezy than the other entries in the series but is still a solid actioner 

by Roger Kanno
February 28, 2022

The King’s Man brings us the origin story of the Kingsman film franchise, whose previous films starred Taron Egerton and Colin Firth as operatives in a fictional British secret service agency. This prequel stars Ralph Fiennes as Duke Orlando Oxford, a British spy at the turn of the century who establishes the Kingsman organization around the time of World War I. Unlike the first two films, which take place during modern times, The King’s Man eschews much of the breezy comedic feel and use of pop music to augment the fast-paced action. There are still comedic elements but this latest installment is more serious in tone. And as it tries to find its own identity, I couldn’t help but feel it would benefit by more fully committing to its darker narrative and leave behind the light-hearted elements of its predecessors. (Think James Mangold’s Logan and what it did for the X-Men franchise.) 

Still, Fiennes does an admirable job as the upper-crust gentleman who secretly protects England and the world from the evil plans of a group known as the Flock led by the Shepherd, even though his understated and sophisticated demeanor sometimes seem a bit out of place amongst all the action. He is joined by accomplished actors such as Djimon Hounsou and Daniel Brühl, but it is Gemma Arterton who shines as the strong-willed and intelligent former member of Orlando’s household staff whom he has recruited into his spy ring. She plays her character with both style and humor while always maintaining proper British restraint. As with the previous films, The King’s Man is written and directed by Matthew Vaughn who has worked on X-Men prequels as well as Layer Cake, Stardust, and Kick Ass, so there is definitely no lack of style or flair in the film’s production.

The King’s Man began streaming on HBO Max and Hulu and made available for purchase or rent from other services on February 18. I accessed it through Google Play, which allowed me to view a 4K version with a 5.1-channel Dolby Digital Plus soundtrack. The picture quality was very good even though it lacked HDR when streamed in this. During a particularly challenging, fast-paced fight sequence, the highly choreographed, ballet-like action showed little artifacting. Even as the villainous Rasputin leaps and pirouettes repeatedly in rapid succession, I could still make out the fine details in his long hair and flowing beard.

When we see the mountain top hideout of the Shepherd, the sun-bathed, snow-covered precipices look stunning, with steely blue and grey rocks contrasted by sparkling white frost and ice. As the scene moves inside the hideout, the picture could have benefitted from HDR enhancement as it loses some sharpness and detail. There was a lack of gradation in shadows as the edges of dark articles of clothing blended together into singular black objects, appearing smooth as they lacked texture on their surfaces. Other than the lack of some highlights in these darker scenes, the overall picture quality was quite satisfying.

The soundtrack is very active, with excellent use of Matthew Margeson’s music score. Throughout action scenes, the orchestral music is used to effectively to fill the soundstage, while sound effects and dialogue remain clearly audible. During an extended battlefield sequence, the constrained but ominous sounds of hand-to-hand combat combined with discordant, driving rhythms, then transitioned to an all-out aural onslaught. As the music surged with strings, horn and choir, mortar shells and automatic gunfire rang out all around as the voices of German and English soldiers were easily discernible amidst the din, which placed me palpably amidst the intense action. 

This third installment of the Kingsman is a bit of departure from the previous two but action fans will likely be drawn to the slickly made prequel. And for those yearning for the return of Eggsy (Egerton) and Harry Hart (Firth), they’re slated to be back in 2023 with the release of Kingsman: The Blue Blood.

Roger Kanno began his life-long interest in home cinema almost three decades ago with a collection of LaserDiscs and a Dolby Surround Pro Logic system. Since then, he has seen a lot of movies in his home theater but has an equal fascination with high-end stereo music systems. Roger writes for both Sound & Vision and the SoundStage! Network.

PICTURE | The image quality is very good, even though it lacks HDR when streamed on Google Play. Particularly challenging action scenes showed little artifacting.

SOUND | The 5.1 Dolby Digital Plus soundtrack is very active. Throughout action scenes, the orchestral music is used to effectively to fill the soundstage while sound effects and dialogue remain clearly audible.

© 2025 Cineluxe LLC

Review: The Power of the Dog

The Power of the Dog (2021)

review | The Power of the Dog

One of this year’s big Oscar favorites, this Netflix western leans more on character and atmosphere than action

by Roger Kanno
February 18, 2022

The Power of the Dog (written and directed by Jane Campion, and based on the novel by Thomas Savage) has received many accolades, including 12 Academy Award nominations, the most of any film this year. It tells the story of the Burbank brothers, Phil (Benedict Cumberbatch) and George (Jesse Plemons), two successful Montana cattlemen in the 1920s who meet Rose Gordon (Kirsten Dunst), a widowed innkeeper, and her son Peter (Kodi Smit-McPhee) during a cattle drive. While the kind-hearted George falls in love with and eventually marries Rose, Phil is unnecessarily cruel to everyone he meets, especially Rose and Peter. 

It is sometimes difficult to watch Cumberbatch, so convincing is his portrayal of the wholly unpleasant Phil, but his performance is never over the top; rather, it’s nuanced and fascinating in an unnerving manner. Real-life couple Plemons and Dunst are just as convincing and no less captivating as the subdued counterparts to the volatile Phil. Smit-McPhee is excellent as the meek, studious young Peter, seemingly out of place among the rough ranch hands. All are deserving of their Oscar nominations. Campion is also nominated for her adapted screenplay, as one of the producers for Best Picture, and as Best Director. The Power of the Dog is both a period piece and a psychological drama, as well as a finely crafted character study of complex individuals. 

Outdoor scenes filmed on location in New Zealand have an austere look, wonderfully capturing the rustic atmosphere of cattle ranching at the end of the Wild West era. The color palette is on the cool side, with dusty cattle-wrangling scenes sometimes showing slight aliasing, but otherwise the picture (shot in ArriRaw at 4.5K and presented in Dolby Vision on Netflix) has excellent sharpness and detail. While the exterior shots are bright and sharp, the dimly lit interiors can look a little soft, but the lighting has a natural organic quality even though the interiors were shot entirely on soundstages. 

Ari Wegner’s cinematography, which was also nominated for an Oscar, is breathtaking, with the untamed New Zealand landscape looking both stark and dazzling. Images are framed with the picturesque scenery in mind, and wide shots will look truly majestic on high-quality video displays. There aren’t a lot of bright primary colors to be seen as exteriors are dominated by dry, prairie-like landscapes and the characters wear mostly earth tones, but the film’s UHD presentation is simply gorgeous in an understated manner.

The Oscar-nominated sound design by Richard Flynn, Robert Mackenzie, and Tara Webb is similarly subdued. The opening scenes start off with well recorded, rambling plucked strings and the atmospheric sounds of a cattle drive on the open plains setting an appropriately melancholic tone. But much of the rest of the film consists of only dialogue, occasional Foley effects, and very limited use of the music score. Foley is often mixed at low levels but is well suited to the onscreen action, and the minimalist sound design meticulously captures the feeling of the story’s setting during simpler times.

The lack of surround presence during most of the film serves to highlight a scene where Phil’s banjo playing emanates from the right surround channel then moves to the front speakers once his presence is established. This sudden use of the surrounds is unexpected and helps to heighten the significance of Phil’s actions. There is more liberal use of Jonny Greenwood’s haunting, Oscar-nominated score near the end of the film as the story builds to its deliberate and satisfying conclusion. 

The Power of the Dog is Campion’s first film in more than ten years, during which time she created two limited television series, Top of the Lake and Top of the Lake: China Girl. Both are slow burns like The Power of the Dog and worth seeking out if you’re a fan of her work, but her return to the big screen is beautiful to look at and an absolutely compelling film. 

Roger Kanno began his life-long interest in home cinema almost three decades ago with a collection of LaserDiscs and a Dolby Surround Pro Logic system. Since then, he has seen a lot of movies in his home theater but has an equal fascination with high-end stereo music systems. Roger writes for both Sound & Vision and the SoundStage! Network.

PICTURE | While the exterior shots in Netflix’ Dolby Vision presentation are bright and sharp, the dimly lit interiors can look a little soft, but the lighting has a natural organic quality even though the interiors were shot entirely on soundstages

SOUND | The Oscar-nominated sound design is subdued, with much of the film consisting of only dialogue, occasional Foley effects, and very limited use of the music score

© 2025 Cineluxe LLC

Review: The Tragedy of Macbeth

The Tragedy of Macbeth (2021)

review | The Tragedy of Macbeth

A provocatively modern take on Shakespeare’s classic, despite being shot on a soundstage in black & white with a square aspect ratio 

by Roger Kanno
January 19, 2022

The Tragedy of Macbeth is Joel Coen’s first directorial effort done without the partnership of his younger brother, Ethan, with whom he has collaborated on nearly 20 films over almost four decades including such critically acclaimed titles as Fargo, No Country for Old Men, and True Grit. The elder Coen’s Macbeth premiered at the New York Film Festival on September 24, 2021, followed by a limited theatrical release on December 25, 2021 and streaming on Apple TV+ as of January 14, 2022.

A streamlined retelling of the Shakespearean tragedy, this film clocks in at only 105 minutes and is presented in black & white with a 1.37 aspect ratio, giving it a unique style. Shot entirely on a soundstage, the sets are sparse and often highly stylized, providing a stark and dreamlike look that becomes as much a part of the narrative as Shakespeare’s verse. The angularity of long hallways juxtaposed with the many arches in Macbeth’s castle and the movement of the players from light to darkness within the castle mirrors the duality in the characters and their actions. All of this is wonderfully captured in Bruno Delbonnel’s exacting cinematography and the direction of Coen with the tight framing required by the standard aspect ratio forcing the viewer to focus on the actors and their dialog.

The casting of Denzel Washington and Frances McDormand as Macbeth and Lady Macbeth might distract purists but their performances, if not conventional, convey the horribly fearful and tortured nature of their characters brilliantly, especially that of Lady Macbeth. The bird-like imagery created by the intensely contorted movements and piercing vocalizations of Kathryn Hunter as the three witches is genius and the recurring motif of birds is revisited repeatedly during the film. This makes for great spectacle, but not without substance as is of course provided by the source material, but also by the committed performances and the film’s artistic vision.

The film was shot in Arriraw (4.5K) color and converted to black & white in post-production, allowing greater control over grayscale, and it looks fantastic in the 4K Dolby Vision presentation on Apple TV+. There is no evidence of black crush, and extremely challenging material such as fades from foggy or cloudy, irregular backgrounds, and the dim flickering light from candles exhibits almost no aliasing. The searing imagery as Banquo moves out of the shadows into a bright light underscores the importance of his musings on the foresight of the prophecies of the three witches. The contrast between the totally black background and the stark foreground lighting place him in sharp relief and highlights the minutiae in the detail of his facial features and the textures of his clothing with exquisite intricacy. 

Stephen Root, whom you may know from the delightfully twisted black comedy Barry, has a brief but comedic scene importantly introducing the literary device of knocking sounds to portend evil. Those knocking sounds and the dripping of water echoed ominously throughout the castle and robustly in my listening room in Dolby Atmos as Lady Macbeth commands, “Out, damned spot; out, I say.” And later, as Macduff’s army approaches, the tolling of bells and the sounds of Macbeth’s panic-stricken subjects fill all of the channels with a satisfying ambience. While surround envelopment and the use of Carter Burwell’s beautifully fitting music score increase as the plot progresses and the drama heightens, I just wish that there had been a bit more generous use of the entire audio palette throughout the film. 

I often find film adaptations of plays and musicals to be rather tedious, especially if they are literal adaptions of the source material as I feel that film requires unique visual elements to engage the viewer. However, The Tragedy of Macbeth succeeds in bringing the play to life with a wonderfully surreal vision of medieval Scotland and the treacherous tale of its protagonist. 

Roger Kanno began his life-long interest in home cinema almost three decades ago with a collection of LaserDiscs and a Dolby Surround Pro Logic system. Since then, he has seen a lot of movies in his home theater but has an equal fascination with high-end stereo music systems. Roger writes for both Sound & Vision and the SoundStage! Network.

PICTURE | The 4K Dolby Vision presentation on Apple TV+ looks fantastic, with no evidence of black crush. Extremely challenging material such as fades from foggy or cloudy, irregular backgrounds and the dim flickering light from candles exhibits almost no aliasing

SOUND | The Atmos mix allows knocking sounds and the dripping of water to echo ominously throughout the castle, while the tolling of bells and the sounds of Macbeth’s panic-stricken subjects as Macduff’s army approaches fill all the channels with a satisfying ambience

© 2025 Cineluxe LLC

Scroll to top