• Type:
  • Genre:
  • Duration:
  • Average Rating:

John Sciacca

Review: The Burning Sea

Mobile Logo
The Burning Sea (2021)

review | The Burning Sea

recent reviews

Sign up for our monthly newsletter
to stay up to date on Cineluxe

This Norwegian film ventures into Hollywood disaster-film territory, but much more intimately

by John Sciacca
April 5, 2022

IMDB lists the combined US and Canada box-office gross for The Burning Sea as $493. And, no, I’m not missing any digits there—it made less than $500 at North American cinemas. So it’s probably a pretty safe bet that, like me, this isn’t a film you saw or even heard about. In fact, it wasn’t until reading a comment about its 4K HDR release on the Kaleidescape Owner’s Forum that I was even aware it existed. And at just $14.99 to purchase, I was willing to give it a watch.

My wife and I are fans of foreign films, but typically these end up being romantic comedies, period pieces, or dramas, and less so major disaster films. According to the film’s tagline—“First came The Wave. Then came The Quake. Prepare for . . . The Burning Sea”—this is the third disaster film from the same creative team. But it doesn’t appear to have anything in common with the other two films other than being about “natural” disasters set in Norway. 

The film opens with documentary-style footage showing drilling-company exec William Lie (Bjorn Floberg) recounting that Norway has enjoyed 50 years of prosperous offshore oil drilling. But after drilling thousands of holes in the ocean floor, a major crack has opened, causing an oil rig to collapse and threatening to destroy up to 350 other rigs on the water, which could produce an apocalyptic catastrophe that would affect the Norwegian coastline and much of Europe for decades. 

The most obvious comparisons here are with Deepwater Horizon, the 2016 film starring Mark Wahlberg that chronicled the true story of the BP oil-rig disaster off the Louisiana coast. But The Burning Sea is certainly smaller and more intimate, focusing less on the disaster and rescue of entire crews and more on Sofia (Kristine Kujath Thorp), a scientist who controls an Eeelume (a kind of eel/torpedo-looking submarine exploration robot), who makes it her mission to find and rescue her boyfriend, Stian (Henrik Bjelland), after he’s abandoned aboard one of the damaged rigs. While there are certainly explosions and rigs collapsing, and some decent CGI, those looking for a massive effects-laden, Hollywood-blockbuster-style disaster film will likely be disappointed. This is more character driven than just a massive explosion-fest. 

In a way, Sofia’s arc reminded me a bit of the terrible, horrible, no good, very bad day Sandra Bullock’s character experienced in Gravity, but on water instead of in space, as she is bounced from one calamity to the next. While the story is a bit predictable—you can see that Stian is going to be the character in peril about a mile away—it’s still interesting to watch, and the 104-minute runtime keeps things moving fairly quickly after the opening act establishes the characters and story. Also, it appears that much of the action is filmed aboard actual oil rigs, giving authenticity to the sets.

There are certainly some barbs about climate change and the damage man has inflicted on the planet, but Burning Sea is more a cautionary tale of what could happen if a series of events caused numerous rigs across a wide section of the ocean to fail. Also, the film really focuses almost solely on the plight of Sofia and Stian and doesn’t really address or deal with the aftermath of the “solution” that would have been an environmental disaster exceeding the oil fires Saddam Hussein lit during the first Gulf War.

Shot on 35mm film, there is no information on the resolution of the home transfer, but I found the images to be mostly high quality. There are a few scenes—long shots of the rigs on the water or really low-lit scenes inside darkened environments like the rigs or the robot lab—that had some noise or were a bit grainy and lacked fine detail and dipped into HD quality, and there is certainly some grain visible in the grey, cloud-filled Norwegian skies. But for the most part, images are clear and sharp throughout, particularly closeups that have actors in tight focus, or things like the textures in blankets and jacket patterns. Like all films, images really look their best in well lit exterior shots when the lens can take in all that light. 

Much of the color palette features earth tones—browns, beiges, rust, and tans—and kind of a steely grey and blue of overcast skies and seas, but these are contrasted with the bright reds of the rescue helicopters, vibrant yellows of emergency vehicles, and the orange safety suits worn by rig workers. 

The HDR grade gives plenty of pop to the blazing red-orange flames of explosions and oil fires, as well as punch to bright overhead lighting inside offices and the rigs, though I did notice a couple of computer screens where the brightness looked a tad blown out. Another area where the grade really helps is in the detail and definition in the grey-cloudy skies, letting you see far more individuality to the shapes rather than just a mass of one color. Also, I never noticed any banding or other noise in the underwater shots, where the bright lights from the Eeelume shining through the water produce myriad shades of similar colors and transitions that can often be problematic without enough bandwidth. 

Home theater fans will love the Dolby TrueHD Atmos audio soundtrack included with the Kaleidescape download. While there is a dubbed English-language audio track (also in Atmos), I implore you to turn the subtitles on and listen to the film with the original actor’s speaking in Norwegian. I turned the English track on just for a moment to check the sound, and the actress voicing Sofia was so off—reminding both me and my wife of Pam from The Office—that it was impossible to take seriously.

This mix is filled with all the things Atmos owners love—from the small environmental details to the big, obvious height effects. The sonics transform your listening room into a completely different environment when the action goes underwater, giving more weight and texture to the sounds of bubbles and rumbles and undersea noises. Every environment has its own sonic quality, whether it’s the whine of hydraulics and machinery, water drips and echoes, or wires and motors in the robot lab and aboard the rigs, or the sounds of phones ringing, keyboards clacking and chatter happening inside offices, or the sounds of waves lapping outside. 

Your height speakers will also come into frequent use, whether it’s the sounds of an aircraft hangar door squealing up overhead, heavy rains lashing a rig, the cacophony of sirens, bells, and alarms, or a pair of jet fighters (F35s?) streaking past overhead. Helicopters also make frequent appearances and flyovers throughout, and the sounds of helos passing overhead and rotor noise abounds. 

While this isn’t a super bass-heavy mix, subwoofers are called into action when appropriate, and can deliver some massive, room-rumbling bass, such as when the rigs explode and vessels are ripped underwater or when large ocean waves are smashing into the rigs. 

If you are looking for an alternative to Hollywood’s typical take on disaster films, The Burning Sea offers a more personal, heroine-led approach, more focused on people than destruction, with an active Dolby Atmos mix that is sure to excite and won’t leave you wondering whether your height speakers are working or not. 

Probably the most experienced writer on custom installation in the industry, John Sciacca is co-owner of Custom Theater & Audio in Murrells Inlet, South Carolina, & is known for his writing for such publications as Residential Systems and Sound & Vision. Follow him on Twitter at @SciaccaTweets and at johnsciacca.com.

PICTURE | A few scenes have some noise or are a bit grainy, lacking fine detail and dipping into HD quality, but for the most part, images are clear and sharp throughout

SOUND | The mix is filled with all the things Atmos owners love, from environmental details to big, obvious height effects, transforming your listening room into a completely different environment when the action goes underwater

Generic selectors
Exact matches only
Search in title
Search in content
Post Type Selectors

© 2023 Cineluxe LLC

Review: Death on the Nile (2022)

Death on the Nile (2022)

review | Death on the Nile (2022)

recent reviews

Sign up for our monthly newsletter
to stay up to date on Cineluxe

Kenneth Branagh, all-star cast in tow, takes another stab at a Christie whodunnit

by John Sciacca
April 3, 2022

Growing up, my mother got me interested in Agatha Christie mysteries, and there was a time in high school when I had lofty plans of plowing through all of her novels. (A mountain I did not even come close to summiting.) But what remained was a love for watching the film versions of her famed detectives Miss Marple and Mr. Hercule Poirot piecing together seemingly incomprehensible clues to determine whodunnit. And the films usually had enough time between remakes that it was always a bit of a surprise to remember who the guilty party—or parties—were. (My particular favorite is Ten Little Indians, though it includes neither Marple nor Poirot.) 

Hollywood has an affinity for revisiting Christies classics, and Kenneth Branagh is the latest director to have caught the remake bug. In 2017, he brought Murder on the Orient Express to the big screen, along with taking on the starring role of mustachioed sleuth Poirot, and now he again returns as both director and star of Death on the Nile.

Christies novels are nearly always packed with characters—all the easier to spread the suspicion around!—and have been able to attract star-laden casts throughout their many remakes. Branagh certainly followed this lead, packing Express with multiple A-listers, including Penelope Cruz, Willem Dafoe, Judi Dench, Johnny Depp, and Michelle Pfeiffer; and he continues that trend here, though dialing the star power down a bit, but still drawing Gal Gadot, Armie Hammer, Letitia Wright, Annette Bening, and Tom Bateman (who is the only other returning character from Express, in the role of Poirots friend, Bouc).

The film opens in 1914 with a bit of non-canonical backstory, showing Poirot developing skills of perception during a battle in World War I and also offering an explanation for his character’s iconic moustache. (Though the stache has never been quite as magnificent as the one Branagh wears here.)

From there we cut to a London nightclub in 1937, where we meet Jackie Bellefort (Emma Mackey) passionately dancing with fiancée Simon Doyle (Armie Hammer). Shortly after, Doyle is introduced to heiress Linnet Ridgeway (Gadot), and it is pretty clear the two are smitten from the start. Cut to a hotel in Egypt, where we are celebrating the wedding of Doyle and Ridgeway, and we continue adding to the cast of characters and eventual suspects.

Jackie is not one to take this jilting lightly, and she has been obsessively following the newlyweds around trying to convince Doyle he still loves her. To escape Jackie, the couple charters a cruise ship for their honeymoon, and the wedding party boards the S.S. Karnak for a luxury cruise down the Nile where the champagne flows nearly as freely as the water. But as the title states, there is a death—more accurately a murder—aboard the Karnak, and it is up to Poirot to investigate and interrogate the passengers in his aggressive manner—He accuses everyone of murder!” “Its a problem, I admit.”—and determine the identity of the guilty party before the boat returns to port.

Shot on 65mm film and taken from a 4K digital intermediate, the film is beautiful to look at, with great attention given to the sets, decoration, and costuming. According to one of the extras, building the Karnak took nearly a full year, and it looks and feels it. Unfortunately, the film was all shot in studios in England—not Morocco, as originally planned—and the exterior scenes are sets, green screen, and CGI, and frequently look it, particularly when showing exteriors of buildings like the hotel in Egypt. But having much of the action take place aboard the Karnak helps anchor it somewhat in reality—even if all the waters and exteriors arent. The recreation of Abu Simbel does look impressive, though, and the resolution helps you appreciate the care that went into its construction.

The film opens in black & white, which can look great in HDR, with its clear extremes of contrast. While we dont get truly inky blacks in this opening, we do get loads of contrast in the trenches and can nearly taste the grit of the war. The movie looks its best in exterior scenes where that huge film frame just soaks up the light and delivers beautiful images, and in closeups, where you can marvel at the detail and attention given to the costumes and numerous fabrics. Notice the texture in jackets, hats, shirts, and dresses, where you can clearly see the different details, the pinpoint stitching, weaves, weights, and sheens of each. The Karnaks exterior, with its clean, tight lines and rows of slats covering doors and windows down the side of the ship, also looks appropriately sharp. 

The large film frame also provides great depth of field, making long shots clear and in focus. While they arent real, notice the pyramids Poirot studies or the crowds in the market and how everyone is sharp and clear. This also delivers terrific detail on actorsfaces as the camera comes in tight. 

The HDR grade is used to deliver some punchy, bright whites when needed, such as the stage and dance-floor lighting in the club or the beautiful golden hues of fire-lit rooms inside Abu Simbel or the warm red-orange-gold Nile sky and waters illuminated at sunrise/set. There’s a shot of the Karnak all lit up at night that also looks particularly stunning. The HDR grade also provides some nice pop to the bright white of Poirots suit against the Egyptian desert sands, but also has enough range to easily distinguish the white color differences and layers between shades of white in dinner jackets and shirts. 

Via Kaleidescape, Death on the Nile includes a Dolby TrueHD Atmos surround mix, and while it isnt overly aggressive, it certainly serves the story. I found some of the dialogue—particularly in the nightclub with blues singer Salome (Sophie Okonedo)—to be a bit chesty,” but otherwise it is pretty coherent. 

The audio mix is mostly used to serve up atmospheric sounds that place you in the scene, whether it’s the cacophony of the crowded markets in Egypt with voices and shouts around, the way voices echo within Abu Simbel, or the swirling winds of a sand storm. It is often the quieter moments in Nile where the mix proves its mettle subtly, such as when characters are standing outside talking, where youll notice the gentle sound of water lapping, insects buzzing, birds, or the soft sound of wind rustling, or aboard the Karnak where there is the background sounds of the bassy engine and paddle turning.

Dont expect your subwoofer to give a lot of flex here, but there are a couple of moments where deep bass is called on and it delivers, such as an explosion during the opening flashback, when the Karnark drops its heavy anchor, or when a heavy stone breaks away and falls. 

At over two hours, Death on the Nile is a bit long and drags in parts. And even though the character list has been trimmed from Christies novel, keeping up with everyone and their relationships and backstory can still be a bit much. (As with all of her works, just assume that everyone is connected to the victim and has a motive, no matter how abstract.) But, for the sharp-eyed, the clues are there and this is a solvable mystery, even for those sans moustache. Niles true saving grace is its look and style, and it certainly makes for a beautiful evening up on a luxury display. 

Probably the most experienced writer on custom installation in the industry, John Sciacca is co-owner of Custom Theater & Audio in Murrells Inlet, South Carolina, & is known for his writing for such publications as Residential Systems and Sound & Vision. Follow him on Twitter at @SciaccaTweets and at johnsciacca.com.

PICTURE | The movie looks its best in exterior scenes where the huge film frame just soaks up the light and delivers beautiful images, and in closeups, where you can marvel at the detail and attention given to the costumes and numerous fabrics  

SOUND | While the Atmos mix isnt overly aggressive, it serves the story well—although some of the dialogue can be a bit chesty.” 

Generic selectors
Exact matches only
Search in title
Search in content
Post Type Selectors

© 2023 Cineluxe LLC

Oscars 2022: The Most Demo-Worthy Scenes

Oscars 2022: The Most Demo-Worthy Scenes

Oscars 2022 | The Most Demo-Worthy Scenes

Kaleidescape customers’ favorite scenes from this year’s Oscar nominees turn out to be—not surprisingly—great home theater demos as well

by John Sciacca
March 22, 2022

The Cineluxe reviews team has been diligently watching and reviewing as many of this year’s nominated films as possible, with 27 reviews posted. With the Oscars being handed out on March 27, there isn’t a lot of time left to check out any of the movies you may have missed. No worries! With the help of Kaleidescape, we’ve compiled a list of the top-viewed scenes from many of the nominees, giving you a chance to take a quick sample and get a taste of the film or just refresh your memory before the big event.

Besides delivering films in the highest audio and video quality available anywhere, Kaleidescape bookmarks the pivotal scenes and songs within a film. These are often the defining moments, like “The Cantina” from Star Wars: A New Hope, “Running from the Boulder” from Raiders of the Lost Ark, or “Wounded in the Buttocks” from Forrest Gump

Not too surprisingly, the three films that dominated the Top 25 scenes viewed by Kaleidescape owners were all big, action-filled blockbusters bursting with replayable, demo-worthy moments. Shang-Chi and the Legend of the Ten Rings had five of the highest-ranking scenes, including Nos. 1, 2, and 3, while Dune and No Time to Die  grabbed seven of the Top 25.

Below are some selections from the 65 most-watched scenes, with each scene’s viewing popularity rank out of the 65 and running time.

Cruella

“Cruella Has Arrived” (No. 31 |  3:55)
The film’s Oscar-nominated costume design is on fine display here as Cruella makes her grand entrance into the Baronness’s black-and-white ball. The home is filled with partygoers wearing a variety of formal outfits observing the dress code (“No color”) when Cruella makes a huge splash by first destroying a champagne tower and then burning off her white outer coat to reveal a show-stealing blood-red dress. You can practically hear each piece of glass shatter and skitter across the wood floor before music fills the room as Cruella refuses to go quietly.

“Rebelliousness Turns to Guilt” (No. 35 | 3:56)
At just 7 minutes into the film, we meet young Estella sneaking her way into a party at a mansion filled with people dressed in French Revolution-era garb (again showing off why Cruella was nominated for costume and makeup). Notice the sheer volume, variety, and attention to detail on all the outfits as the camera pans around the room, the 4K HDR transfer giving texture to all the different fabrics.

Dune (2021)

“The Harkonnens Arrive” (No. 6 | 2:20)
Coming about halfway in, this is the most traditionally sci-fi blockbuster-esque action sequence in the film, so it’s no real surprise that it’s the most popular scene from Dune. You get a really good sense of the film’s excellent visual effects and sound design. But viewed outside the context of the story, it’s mostly just “loud things go boom,” which certainly makes it appealing as home-cinema demo material.

“Saving the Miners” (No. 7 | 5:40)
A little over an hour in, this stunning rescue sequence is probably the best in the entire film for demonstrating Dune‘s seamless effects work and its innovative and intense sound design. It’s also the best subwoofer demo of the year, thanks largely to the underground undulations of the mostly unseen—but heard and felt—sandworm.

“A Test of Control” (No. 9 | 4:45)
This is the scene director Denis Villeneuve had to get right for his Dune adaptation to be effective. It’s a master class in costume design, sound mixing, cinematography, and economy of storytelling, and the performances are simply spot-on. HDR grading is also brilliantly used to add depth and nuance to an incredibly dark scene. 

Encanto

“We Don’t Talk About Bruno” (No. 16 | 3:36)
Never doubt the musical prowess of Lin-Manuel Miranda, who co-wrote this catchy tune you’ve probably heard even if you haven’t watched Encanto, as it recently hit No. 1 on the Billboard Hot 100 chart, making “Bruno” the second Disney song ever top reach No. 1! (“A Whole New World” from Aladdin was the first to do so in 1993.) My daughter Audrey loves this song and plays it on Spotify all the time! The Atmos mix helps you appreciate the layering of voices during this ensemble number, which completely fill the room and come from all sides.

“The Family Madrigal” (No. 20 |  4:16)
This song plays right after the opening title comes up and is my personal favorite from the film, introducing us to all the members of the family Madrigal and their special gifts. Note the bright vibrant colors—especially the flowers that bloom around Isabella—and the glowing gold on the family’s doors. The music is the sonic star of the Atmos soundtrack, giving voices space to spread across the front of the room and even up into the ceiling. It also helps you better understand Miranda’s signature rapid-fire lyrics.

Free Guy

“Getting His Own Sunglasses” (No. 19 | 3:12)
At 11 minutes in, Guy, beginning to realize he can be something special, decides to stop being an NPC and fight back against a bank robber. Once he puts on the glasses, he sees the world in a whole new light, filled with bright graphics and power-ups. The audio definitely immerses you in Free City, with a jet that flies overhead, along with sounds of helicopters and traffic off in the distance.

“Dude vs. Guy” (No. 26 | 4:46)
At 1 hour 28 in, this scene is the Boss Fight, with Guy having to fight a super-sized—yet unfinished—version of himself named Dude. Dude’s Death Blow punches produce room-energizing bass, but Guy has some power-ups of his own and there are a couple of great MCU and Star Wars tie-ins that are sure to bring a smile to your face.

Luca

“The Swim to Portorosso” (No. 8 | 1:11)
At 27 minutes in, this scene highlights the bright and beautiful colors throughout Luca, as Luca and Alberto swim to “Vespa town” (aka Portorosso), jumping in and out of the water as they change from sea monster to human and back. Pixar’s animation skills in rendering the ocean—both above and below—and the varied shades of blue are on full display.

“First Time Houseguests” (No. 12 | 3:05)
Luca and Alberto visit Giulia and her dad for dinner, trying to keep their secret from the great fisherman. Notice the attention to detail throughout the scene— from the fine detail in dad’s sweater, to the glassware, to the trenette al pesto he prepares, where you can see the noodles slick with olive oil and highlights on the basil leaves.

No Time to Die

“We’re Leaving” (No. 4 | 5:16)
At 18 minutes in, this takes place shortly after the scene below, but it is one of the film’s highlights, and if you ever wanted to see the glorious Aston Martin DB-5 from Goldfinger flex its muscles, this scene is for you! Bond races through the curvy, stone-paved Italian hills before being “trapped” in the city center. The audio is fantastic, with the screech of tires and the revving engine, the chime of church bells filling the room, and the hail of gunfire and thunk of bullets hitting into the bullet-resistant glass coming from all around, placing you in the car with Bond—right up until he decides to let the DB-5 unleash Hell!

“Cemetery Visit Cut Short” (No. 5 | 2:46)
Occurring 15 minutes in, the scene begins immediately after Bond is blown up after visiting an old friend’s grave. He gives chase on foot across an old bridge in Southern Italy but is ambushed by armed gunmen in a car and motorcycle. Bond ultimately steals the bike and makes a bold getaway, but pull your eyes away from the action long enough to appreciate the cinematography. It’s filled with wide vistas and an ancient city in the background, all beautifully illuminated in the naturallighting.

Raya and the Last Dragon

“A Betrayal of Trust” (No. 50 | 4:54)
At 15 minutes in, young Raya shows her tribe’s sacred dragon gem to Namaari, who decides to steal it for her tribe. During the struggle to take the gem, it shatters, releasing the Druun, whose touch turns people to stone. This is another showcase for HDR, with the dragon gem glowing a beautiful blue-white in the dark inner temple, and the Druun having a vibrant glowing-purple effect. The sound design is also great, with deep bassy rumbles and crackling stones as the gem shatters and the temple starts collapsing, causing people to flee in all directions.

“Tail’s Dragon Gem” (No. 55 | 4:13)
Here a grown Raya is partnered with last dragon Sisu as they retrieve another lost piece of the dragon gem. Fine details in the animation abound, from Sisu’s fur, to Raya’s leather arm band, to the individual leaves on the tree, to the vest worn by Namaari. Near the end, the exploding toot-and-boom bugs leave a vibrant cloud of HDR-glowing colors before Ray and Sisu jump on Tuk Tuk and roll to freedom, riding off a cliff into the water.

Shang-Chi and the Legend of the Ten Rings

“The Battle Begins” (No. 1 | 5:33)
Near the film’s end, this is the prelude to the big finale as two armies face-off in Ta Lo. Note the wide-open outdoor sounds of wind rustling leaves and water in the quiet opening moments. Once the fighting starts, the mystical weapons have vibrant blue and red-orange colors enhanced by HDR, and this battle involves dozens of fighters fighting and being tossed all around the room. The scene ends with a battle between Shang-Chi and his father Xu Wenwu, which is fast and full of action.

“The Ten Rings” (No. 2 | 2:26)
Taking place a few minutes after the above scene, Shang-Chi continues his battle with Xu and takes control of the mystical rings. The visual effects are on full display here, with the rings encircling and protecting Shang-Chi and Xu fighting with his own set of rings that he uses as a whip, with the rings glowing and crackling in bright colors. This scene also has some great low-frequency extension, with impacts that will flex your subwoofers and energize the room.

“A High-Rise Obstacle” (No. 3 | 4:52)
At 38 minutes in, this scene has all the ingredients for a great demo—a clear beginning and end, easy to understand, lots of action, and it doesn’t spoil the film! Shot at night outside a high-rise building in Macau, it has a much different look than the other scenes. Shang is trying to escape a group of assailants as he scrambles around on scaffolding, while also keeping friend Katy safe. Night city scenes always look beautiful in 4K HDR, and this has plenty of pop from the surrounding buildings and great depth of field as you look down through the scaffolding. There is also a lot of Atmos audio excitement with things smashing, crashing, and falling all around.

West Side Story

“Tony Meets Maria” (No. 62 | 2:47)
This takes place about 39 minutes in, after the terrific, long single-take shot following The Sharks into the gym and the Mambo dance. A meet-cute between Tony and Maria under the bleachers at the big dance, the scene is lit in dreamy pink and blue lighting, with bright lights streaming in through the bleachers illuminating the dance happening a world away behind the characters. The ill-fated couple meets on neutral ground, dance-flirt for a bit, and start falling in love.

“The Rumble” (No. 65 | 7:24)
Happening at the hour-forty mark, this is the climatic territorial showdown between the Jets and Sharks. Taking place in a dark warehouse with bright light streaming in through the windows, the camera circles the fighters and pulls back into long shots, with the audio showing off the space’s wide-open, echoing acoustics.

Probably the most experienced writer on custom installation in the industry, John Sciacca is co-owner of Custom Theater & Audio in Murrells Inlet, South Carolina, & is known for his writing for such publications as Residential Systems and Sound & Vision. Follow him on Twitter at @SciaccaTweets and at johnsciacca.com.

Generic selectors
Exact matches only
Search in title
Search in content
Post Type Selectors

© 2022 Cineluxe LLC

Review: Spider-Man: Far From Home

Spider-Man: Far From Home (2019)

review | Spider-Man: Far From Home

the MCU on Cineluxe

recent reviews

Sign up for our monthly newsletter
to stay up to date on Cineluxe

This second entry in the third franchise reboot helps firmly cement Spider-Man’s position in the MCU

by John Sciacca
September 20, 2019

Like James Bonds—and maybe even Batmans—people undoubtedly have a favorite Spider-Man between Tobey Maguire, Andrew Garfield, and Tom Holland, the latest webslinger to wear the red and blue. For me it has less to do with the man behind the mask—although, I’ll admit to being partial to Holland’s portrayal—and more to do with the storyline and relationships that makes the latest Spider-Man films the best of the bunch.

This third franchise reboot can trace its roots back to Captain America: Civil War, where Tony Stark (Robert Downey Jr.) took young Spidey under his Iron wing, gave him a better suit, and helped him in his fight against Cap and the Avengers. That mentor relationship continued in Spider-Man: Homecoming, Holland’s first turn carrying a film as Peter Parker and Spidey and one that, thankfully, didn’t make us relive the entire “bit by a spider, hunted down my uncle’s killer” origin. Of course, Spider-Man’s relationship with Tony Stark played a role in both Avengers: Infinity War and Endgame, and Far from Home picks up and continues that storyline.

There will be some major story spoilers if you’ve yet to see Endgame, as much of Far from Home’s first act revolves around the ramifications of both Infinity and Endgame. So I would strongly suggest watching both of those films first—plus, they’re just a ton of fun to watch.

Home picks up about 8 months after Endgame, and the world has come to call this time “the Blip.” We get a nice bit of exposition in an opening newscast from Peter’s high school, where we find how the kids are dealing with the ramifications of the Blip, where some have missed five years of their lives, while others who were previously much younger are now older. (If you’ve seen Endgame, you understand.) Peter is still personally reeling from Stark’s death, and he sees signs of Tony/Iron Man literally everywhere. 

During a class trip to Europe, Peter is called on by Nick Fury (Samuel L. Jackson) to help a new superhero, Quentin Beck/Mysterio (Jake Gyllenhaal), who comes from another earth in the Multiverse, battle giant Elementals bent on destroying the planet. Peter is reluctant to help, wanting to just have a chance to relax and be a kid and profess his love for MJ (Zendaya), but Fury rearranges the trip’s itinerary to continue putting Peter in a position to help. Of course, not all is as it seems, and Peter is forced to make some tough decisions while trying to win the girl, save his friends, and keep his identity secret.

As I mentioned, it’s the continued relationships developed over the years of the MCU that make these latest Spidey films so much more enjoyable and feel so much richer. In Home, we get Happy (Jon Favreau) trying to step in as a Stark mentor replacement, while also romancing Aunt May (Marisa Tomei), who looks terrific here. Fury is trying to restructure after losing so many Avengers, and trying to get Spider-Man to step up to fill a bigger role. 

The relationship between Peter and man-in-the-chair Ned (Jacob Batalon) continues, but complicated by a new romantic interest, along with douchey Flash Thompson (Tony Revolori), who admires Spider-Man but loathes Parker. The humor is deftly handled, and there are several references to other Marvel characters. (Pay close attention to the movie options Peter browses for his in-flight film!)

Definitely stick around for both the mid-credits scene—which potentially alters Peter’s life forever—and the post-credits scene, which has a nice callback to another recent Marvel film. And, while it in no way impacts the movie, there is sadly no Stan Lee cameo here.

Far from Home looks fantastic. Filmed in a combination of 2.8 and 3.4K resolution, this transfer is taken from a 2K digital intermediate but it is never wanting for pop or detail. This is a marquee title and it absolutely looks it. Both closeup and long shots have great detail and texture and razor-sharp edge detail with incredible depth and dimension—things like the metallic texture of Spidey’s Iron Spider suit or the fine detail in Ned’s hat. 

The film travels through three major European cities, which all have their own look. While in Venice, many of the scenes are outdoors during the day, and the city looks so beautiful you could be watching a travelogue. At night, interiors are lit by the soft glow of lamps, revealing warm and natural colors. In contrast, much of the scenes in Prague are at night, and we get the bright lights and color of fireworks at a carnival.

Home definitely benefits from the high dynamic range and wide color gamut of UltraHD, and both are used well throughout to push images to their best. From the vivid red of Spidey’s suit, to Mysterio’s green blasts, to the broiling red-orange of the Fire Elemental, images pop off the screen when they should. Also, HDR just lends an overall better sense of depth to the image. Black levels are also deep and clean, with clear differences between shades of black, such as Happy’s black suit, Peter’s black shirt and pants and Fury’s black leather trench coat and turtleneck. The images are all reference-quality and offer no room for criticism.

The Dolby Atmos track is also an absolute treat, with near constant and aggressive use of the surround and height speakers. There’s a scene in a hotel in Venice where you hear workers hammering overhead even with no visible construction happening on screen, which is a great audio moment letting you know exactly what’s going on even without seeing it. 

The battles also offer a complete hemispherical experience, with things crashing and being destroyed all around or water splashing and raining down from the ceiling. Another scene where Spidey is inside the Illusion has voices swirling constantly overhead, moving from speaker to speaker all around and above you, creating a sonic illusion I don’t think I’ve heard in any other film. 

Available now for download in 4K HDR from the Kaleidescape Store a full two weeks before the physical disc is released, Spider-Man: Far from Home is a fun and engaging movie that looks and sounds fantastic, making for a great home cinema selection. 

Probably the most experienced writer on custom installation in the industry, John Sciacca is co-owner of Custom Theater & Audio in Murrells Inlet, South Carolina, & is known for his writing for such publications as Residential Systems and Sound & Vision. Follow him on Twitter at @SciaccaTweets and at johnsciacca.com.

PICTURE | The transfer is taken from a 2K digital intermediate but is never wanting for pop or detail

SOUND | The Atmos track is an absolute treat, with near constant and aggressive use of the surround and height speakers

Generic selectors
Exact matches only
Search in title
Search in content
Post Type Selectors

© 2023 Cineluxe LLC

Review: Spider-Man: No Way Home

Spider-Man (2021)

review | Spider-Man: No Way Home

This billion-dollar-grossing endorphin rush is packed with demo scenes that will give your home theater a workout

by John Sciacca
March 18, 2022

Many people had looked at the recent dire returns at the box office and declared the death of commercial cinema. But then along came Spider-Man: No Way Home to shatter all manner of box-office records: Highest-grossing film (by far) in 2021 after just two weeks at the box office, sixth highest-grossing film ever, first film since Star Wars: The Rise of Skywalker in 2019 to gross over $1 billion, third-fastest film ever to reach the Big B milestone, and first to do so in the pandemic era. 

So, clearly, if you give the people what they want, they’ll come back to the theater to see it. And what they want seems to be the escapism of big-budget superhero films. (Need further proof? The Batman is currently the highest-grossing film of 2022. No Way Home is second.)

This is the third film in Tom Holland’s Spider arc and is a direct sequel to 2019’s Spider-Man: Far From Home, but much in the way Avengers: Endgame was the culmination of 11 years and 21 films’ worth of Marvel Cinematic Universe buildup, No Way Home is far more than just a single film. And while it’s certainly possible to enjoy this movie on its own, to really appreciate the entirety of the story you should at least watch the two previous Holland films. 

But those looking for the deepest dive and the most emotional connection (and payoff) should also revisit the original Tobey Maguire Spider-Man trilogy (2002, 2004, and 2007) and the Andrew Garfield The Amazing Spider-Man (2012 and 2014) films as well as the animated Spider-man Into the Spider-Verse. Fortunately, this is a perfect time for a rewatch as all of those films (with the exception of the first Spider-Man) are available in 4K HDR with new Atmos mixes via Kaleidescape, and I can attest that they all look and sound fantastic, with some really exciting and immersive surround. 

No Way Home begins immediately after the mid-credits scene from Far From Home, right after Mysterio (Jake Gyllenhaal) frames Spidey for the UK attacks and then announces to the world that Spider-Man is really Peter Parker, with the film’s first act having Peter (Holland), girlfriend MJ (Zendaya), and best friend/guy-in-the-chair Ned (Jacob Batalon) coming to terms with the world suddenly knowing Peter’s identity. 

Of course, when you’re friends with a wizard named Doctor Strange (Benedict Cumberbatch), you can just ask him to cast a forgetting spell that makes the world forget who Spider-Man is. But when Strange is interrupted during the casting process, well, the broken spell causes a rift in the multi-verse, drawing people from other universes.

I really enjoyed this movie, and it is up there as one of my favorites in the entire MCU. I saw it in the theater and couldn’t wait to watch it again at home, and I’m happy to say that not only did it hold up on a second viewing, the 4K HDR picture and Dolby TrueHD Atmos sound from the Kaleidescape download were truly reference-quality throughout.

Shot on Arri at 4.5K, this transfer is taken from a 2K digital intermediate but you’d never know it as images are pristine and full of detail throughout. From the opening moments, you’ll notice just how clean, clear, and razor-sharp everything looks, letting you appreciate all the texture and detail of Spidey’s suit. Edges of buildings are also sharp and clearly defined with no jaggies or aliasing. There’s also a ton of depth to the images, with several shots appearing near 3D such as when Spidey is swinging along or an overhead pan looking down on the city from way up, and another shot in a cemetery with the individual branches and limbs of a tree having a ton of dimensionality. You also get incredibly fine facial detail on closeups or the ability to see individual grains of sand that drop and shift off one character. 

The HDR grade gives the images a ton of pop but also delivers really natural-looking outside daytime shots on the city streets or low-lit interior and exterior night shots. There are a few shots at sunset that have a wonderful warm, golden glow, and also some scenes in Strange’s “crypt” lit by low overhead lights casting the room in nice shadow. 

One scene that really stood out was after a nighttime attack on an apartment building where there was hazy smoke all around. In the chaos, there are car headlights, flashing police lights, fire, and even lasers. There’s a ton happening here visually compounded by all the light diffusing through the smoke and darkness without any banding or other video artifacts. 

While black levels throughout the film are mostly deep, the opening credits, end credits, and one complete fade to nothing in the middle of the film are just a dark grey—noticeably far lighter in color than the pure black of the letterbox bars above and below the image. Having become accustomed to the utter and complete blackness my Sony OLED can produce, this was worth mentioning.

Other highlights include Spidey’s suit, which is a deeply saturated red, effects like Doctor Strange’s magic with its glowing golden rings, bright blasts of electricity that crackle and streak across the sky, the vibrant greens of the Daily Fix studios and monitors, and a vibrant purple that rips across the sky. 

The Dolby TrueHD Atmos soundtrack will give your theater a workout with tons of immersive audio that comes from all around and overhead. There are lots of small atmospheric moments like winds that whistle and the echo of voices while talking in Strange’s mansion, water drips falling around the room in Strange’s crypt, the wide-open sounds of a forest at night, or the general traffic noises in the city. 

There are also plenty of the big, demo-worthy surround moments you’d expect, including numerous helicopters throughout that hover high up in front of the room or sail off into the sides and back or zip overhead. Other examples include a scene where a glider swoops overhead, or one inside the “mirror dimension” when the sound wraps up from the sides and overhead, or when a villain flings cars and items that crash and smash all around. Or check out the magic circles that swirl overhead and around the room, or when Peter goes on top of a car and you hear his voice travel overhead and across the top of the room. 

There’s also plenty of deep low-frequency info for your sub to dig into and energize the room. Whether it’s the heavy thunk of Strange’s doors opening or closing, the massive impact sounds of one villain’s arms smashing and grabbing things, the crackle and rumble as the multi-verse tears open, shattering concrete and collapsing girders, or bombs exploding, the bass is big and tactile. 

At 148 minutes, No Way Home is long, but it’s so filled with action, characters, humor, and heart-filled moments that it zips by. By the time you get to the finale—which is huge, cinematic, and full of heart, risk, and payoff, and crammed with effects and sonic bombast—you’ll have that endorphin rush that almost feels like you’ve completed a workout. This movie is reference-quality throughout, and is easy to recommend! 

Probably the most experienced writer on custom installation in the industry, John Sciacca is co-owner of Custom Theater & Audio in Murrells Inlet, South Carolina, & is known for his writing for such publications as Residential Systems and Sound & Vision. Follow him on Twitter at @SciaccaTweets and at johnsciacca.com.

PICTURE | The transfer is taken from a 2K digital intermediate but you’d never know it as images are pristine and full of detail throughout 

SOUND | The Atmos soundtrack will give your theater a workout with tons of immersive audio that comes from all around and overhead 

Generic selectors
Exact matches only
Search in title
Search in content
Post Type Selectors

© 2023 Cineluxe LLC

Review: Spider-Man: Into the Spider-Verse

Spider-Man: Into the Spider-Verse (2019)

review | Spider-Man: Into the Spider-Verse

the MCU on Cineluxe

recent reviews

Sign up for our monthly newsletter
to stay up to date on Cineluxe

This Oscar winner inventively scrambles what you’d expect from an animated feature, forever rewriting the rules 

by John Sciacca
March 6, 2019

I didn’t really have a lot of desire to see Spider-Man: Into the Spider-Verse when it was in movie theaters. Nothing about the trailer really grabbed me, but when it started getting rave reviews both from critics (97% on Rotten Tomatoes, with comments like “It is a game changer”) and audiences (94% positive), I figured maybe the trailer didn’t resonate with me but the film would. Then, when it took home the Academy Award this year for Animated Feature Film, that clinched it.

This is and also totally isn’t the Spider-Man story you know. It begins with the Peter Parker (voiced by Chris Pine) we’ve always known and has animated versions of several of the marquee scenes you’ll likely remember from the multiple live-action Spider-Man movies from recent years. But the real star is teenaged Miles Morales (voiced by Shameik Moore), who was unknowingly bitten by a radioactive spider (don’t you hate when that happens?) and then crosses paths with Parker while he is in the midst of battling some baddies to save Brooklyn (again). During the battle, a particle accelerator opens up portals to alternate universes, bringing five alternate Spider-people into Brooklyn, where they all work together to stop Kingpin from unleashing the accelerator that could destroy not only our world but the entire universe. 

I loved Spider-Man: Homecoming for a few of reasons. One, it didn’t get bogged down in its own origin story, forcing us to relive —once again—how Spider-Man becomes Spider-Man. At this point we all know the story, and this was a theme Spider-Verse repeatedly poked fun at. Two, after the recent Toby Maguire and Andrew Garfield outings, Tom Holland’s Spidey just felt fresh and new, more wide-eyed and trying to figure things out. Three, it gave us a great sidekick in Ned (Jacob Batalon), who provided a much needed second personality as well as adding enough Tony Stark/Iron Man to keep the film feeling bigger than just “another Spider-Man” movie, while also giving it a place in the much larger Marvel universe.

Those things equally apply to Spider-Verse, which feels both the same (but in a good way) and yet totally new and fresh. What really sets this movie apart is its unique visual style. As much as I loved Ralph Breaks the Internet and The Incredibles 2—also nominated in the Best Animated Feature category—after watching Spider-Verse, it’s not a surprise it took home the Oscar as it has an innovative style and look unlike anything that has come before it. You can tell you’re in for something different right from the opening Columbia title screen. 

Animation always looks fantastic in 4K HDR and this is no different. The colors are bright and vivid and pushed to the boundaries, with the reds of Spidey’s suit particularly vibrant and heavily saturated. The blacks are also deep, with HDR used throughout to provide extra punch. 

The look of Spider-Verse constantly changes throughout the movie, often during the same scene, and it definitely embraces its comic-book roots, with a style that often feels like comic panels brought to life. At times, images are near photo-realistic, then switch to a cartoon panel-style, then to the Pop Art style of Roy Lichtenstein. The image has an incredible depth of focus that looks truly 3D at times. Frequently, things in the near- or background are heavily blurred to make you focus on specific portions of the frame. The style in some scenes reminded me of the film-noir storytelling style of the Max Payne video game from years ago.

Beyond the visuals, a modern animated film often succeeds or fails based on the quality of the story and voice acting. While the theme of a band of strangers coming together to defeat a common enemy is nothing new, Spider-Verse never feels like a retread and manages to work in enough pop culture references to be clever.

The voicing is great, with Nicolas Cage as the black & white Spider-Man Noir, a private eye from 1933 who likes to drink egg creams and fight Nazis. Jake Johnson brings his hilarious Nick Miller New Girl vibe and mannerisms to Peter B. Parker, a Spidey who has gone through a nasty breakup and let himself go. John Mulaney does a good job with Peter Porker, aka Spider-Ham, though something about his delivery reminded me of Nathan Lane’s Timon from The Lion King. (Also, I couldn’t get “Spider-Pig, Spider-Pig, does whatever a Spider Pig does. . .” out of my head whenever I saw Spider-Ham.) 

The Dolby Atmos audio mix is very aggressive, with many discrete effects routed to all channels and lots of height information. There is also some serious low-frequency information that will rattle your windows and slam you in the chest. Dialogue is well recorded and remains easy to understand regardless what world-ending event is happening onscreen. 

Spider-Verse is a fresh take on the superhero genre and a visually stunning film that will look fantastic in a home theater and is sure to entertain family members of all ages. 

Probably the most experienced writer on custom installation in the industry, John Sciacca is co-owner of Custom Theater & Audio in Murrells Inlet, South Carolina, & is known for his writing for such publications as Residential Systems and Sound & Vision. Follow him on Twitter at @SciaccaTweets and at johnsciacca.com.

PICTURE | Colors are bright and vivid and pushed to the boundaries, with the reds of Spider-Man’s suit particularly vibrant and heavily saturated. The blacks are also deep, with HDR used throughout to provide extra punch. 

SOUND | The Atmos mix is very aggressive, with many discrete effects routed to all channels and lots of overhead height information

Generic selectors
Exact matches only
Search in title
Search in content
Post Type Selectors

© 2023 Cineluxe LLC

Review: Turning Red

Turning Red (2022)

review | Turning Red

related reviews

Sign up for our monthly newsletter
to stay up to date on Cineluxe

The latest Pixar offering falls squarely into so-so territory, way closer to Luca than Soul

by John Sciacca
March 14, 2022

The term “dumping ground” certainly has negative connotations but it seems an apt description for how Disney has been using Disney+ for recent Pixar films. Once the crown jewel of animated titles, expected to generate upwards of $1 billion in worldwide box office per film, the past three Pixar features, including its latest, Turning Red (which debuted on Friday March 11), have all skipped the theater and been released directly onto the streaming service without even requiring the add-on “Premier Access” fee for early viewing.

One of the things you typically expect from Pixar is a multi-faceted story that appeals across multiple generations. At the studio’s best—Inside Out, Toy Story 3, Soulit creates stories and characters with so much depth and emotion it can bring viewers to tears. (I swear, the end of Toy Story 3 gets me every time.) 

While it was beautiful-looking, I felt Pixar’s last film, Luca, was an especially weak and overly sweet entry in its oeuvre, especially following Soul, which tackled such deep and heady topics. I’d like to say the studio returned to form with Turning Red, its 25th feature, but it just lacked the depth I was hoping for. 

Red is directed and co-written by Domee Shi, who previously helmed the 2018 Pixar short Bao, which I thought was wonderful. In that sub-eight-minute film, she gave us a full emotional story arc that made us care for a dumpling that served as a metaphor for the mother’s love for her son and him growing up.

Shi clearly understands and is interested in sharing Chinese culture, and she doesn’t stray from that here. Meilin (Rosalie Chiang) is an overachieving 13-year-old girl currently in Grade 8 growing up in Canada. She has a ride-or-die crew of three friends who are starting to notice boys and want nothing more than to see boy-band sensation 4*Town in concert when they come to Toronto during an upcoming tour. But, of course, Meilin’s tiger mom, Ming (Sandra Oh), has objections to this. Complicating things is that, due to an ancient family blessing/curse, Meilin—like all the women in her family when they reach a certain age—has started suddenly transforming into a large red panda whenever she gets too excited or is overcome with emotions. And, as a teenager, this is nearly all the time. 

In some ways, Turning Red reminded me of a different take or follow-on to Inside Out, however not as brilliant or entertaining. But this is more of an “outside in,” as we see all the external things Meilin is going through and how they affect her emotions. As the parent of a teenage daughter, there’s a lot that’s relatable here and the “not a girl, not yet a woman” purgatory that can be the teenage years. The film’s core message is about growing up, changing, and developing into adulthood and discovering your own self, but without disappointing family or leaving it behind. 

One area where I’m happy to say Pixar is still very much on point is picture quality. The studio seems to raise the bar on the technical capabilities of its computer animation with each film, and that is certainly on display here. Turning Red is visually stunning, and you could pick any frame and dissect the shading, texturing, lighting, and detail that went into it.

Taken from a 4K digital intermediate, the subtle textures really stood out. Things like the texture in a metallic name tag Meilin wears working at the family temple, the tight herringbone pattern in a hat, a rubber dodge ball, the fuzzy/furry textures of Meilin’s stuffed toy animals, or the natural shimmer and texture of the fabric on the emerald-colored blazer Ming wears. And the detail and movement in the fur work when Meilin is Red Panda is a clear evolution from Sully in Monsters Inc. 

The animators show incredible attention to even the smallest details, such as single strands of stray fabric on a hat or sweater or a loose strand of hair. In one scene, Meilin is shown in profile lit by moonlight through a window, and you see these fine tiny hairs on her chin and neck. Or notice the smoke curling off the incense sticks in the temple as it softly coils and winds its way towards the ceiling while slowly dissipating. 

There is definitely more stylized animation here. For example, when characters are overwhelmed by something’s cuteness, they will get large, starry manga eyes, and there are also a lot of lighting effects that are very anime-inspired. There’s a scene about 9:30 into the film where the dad is cooking that’s especially stunning, causing everyone in our family to literally say, “Wow!” at the same instant. It’s near photo-realistic animation that is just beautiful to behold, and I’d happily watch an entire show of nothing but the dad preparing a meal in that style and quality. Also, stay through the end credits for another scene that is incredibly lifelike.

There is plenty of red here, which is an extremely auspicious color in Chinese culture, and the HDR with Dolby Vision grade helps it to really pop, as do the many scenes around town colored with bright pinks and pastels. Also notice the color shading in Meilin’s red hair, with its blended layers and shades of red, orange, and yellow. Near the end, she visits a magical bamboo forest where there are a lot of vibrant and glowing lighting effects. 

The Dolby Atmos soundtrack has a good bit of atmosphere and immersion but, like with many of Disney’s recent sound mixes, I found myself pushing the volume knob about 5 dB louder than usual. The mix’s primary goal is clearly presenting the dialogue and it pulls that off well, but there’s a nuance to the quality of the audio here depending on the environment where characters are speaking. For example, voices in Meilin’s small, tiled bathroom have a completely different tonal quality than when they’re speaking inside the temple or shouting in the bamboo forest. 

Outdoor scenes have plenty of ambient surround effects such as traffic sounds, or thunder that cracks and rolls overhead, or the rustling of bamboo branches and leaves in a forest. Notice the calming Zen music and gentle, room-filling chimes, the winds that blow through the temple, the voices chanting all around you, or the arena atmosphere at the 4*Town concert. 

Your subwoofer gets a bit of work, giving some serious heft to the panda’s giant footsteps, or when Meilin poofs into the panda during one especially embarrassing moment at school, or for the panda’s booming voice, or during the concert.

Turning Red seems to have critics and audiences split, with critics giving it a 95% Rotten Tomatoes rating, matching both Soul and Wall-E, and audiences scoring it a more mediocre 66%, closer to The Good Dinosaur’s 64%. While I didn’t find Turning Red to be among Pixar’s strongest outings, it’s entertaining and looks fantastic, and certainly worth checking out for Disney+ subscribers. 

Probably the most experienced writer on custom installation in the industry, John Sciacca is co-owner of Custom Theater & Audio in Murrells Inlet, South Carolina, & is known for his writing for such publications as Residential Systems and Sound & Vision. Follow him on Twitter at @SciaccaTweets and at johnsciacca.com.

PICTURE | Subtle textures really stand out in the 4K presentation, and the near photo-realistic animation is just beautiful to behold

SOUND | The Atmos soundtrack has a good bit of atmosphere and immersion but, as with many of Disney’s recent mixes, is about 5 dB softer than it should be

Generic selectors
Exact matches only
Search in title
Search in content
Post Type Selectors

© 2023 Cineluxe LLC

Review: West Side Story

review | West Side Story recent reviews Apple TV+ | CODA Google Play | Rifkin’s Festival Kaleidescape | Summer of Soul Apple TV+ | The Tragedy of Macbeth see more in Reviews Sign up for our monthly newsletter to stay up to date on Cineluxe Spielberg takes a stab at musicals with this Oscar-nominated revamping […]

Review: Scream (2022)

Scream (2022)

review | Scream (2022)

also on Cineluxe

Sign up for our monthly newsletter
to stay up to date on Cineluxe

This franchise reboot ups the brutality and gore but fails to top the 1996 original

by John Sciacca
March 10, 2022

While Scream 2 came just a year after the original film debuted in 1996 and Scream 3 was released in 2000, there was an 11-year drought before Scream 4 came out in 2011, followed by another 11 years before this latest franchise entry. I rewatched the original Scream when it received a 4K HDR transfer for its 25th anniversary, and was impressed how well it held up. 

This latest Scream is the first film in the series not directed by franchise creator Wes Craven, who died in 2015. But it remains true to the spirit of the franchise and brings back key cast, including Randy Jackson returning to voice Ghostface, with some quick cameos and voiceovers from actors that have been in the earlier films. I did find the violence to be a bit more brutal and gorier, and the language to be a bit saltier, so definitely not suitable for younger viewers. (Common Sense Media rates it 16+)

Like all of the Scream films, the story is essentially the same: A killer dressed in a Ghostface mask is terrorizing people of Woodsboro, California who are somehow associated with the events from the first film, taunting them on the phone—often discussing horror-movie-related trivia—before attempting to stab them to death. They also do a nice job of updating the tech to keep it current, like having smart-home door locks. And as always, there are certain rules that must be followed to survive, including the most important one: The first victim always has a friend group the killer is part of. 

Many of the film’s subtle references are about Stab, the fictional film-within-the-film based on the events that have transpired in Woodsboro. Here, Stab superfans are really upset over how the series has gone off the rails with the latest release, Stab 8.  As one character tells us, we’re in the middle of a “requel”—not quite a reboot, not quite a sequel. The movie has to be new, but not too new, and it has to be part of an ongoing storyline, having new main characters but supported by and related to legacy characters. Also, “It always, always goes back to the original.”

In this vein, we have a new group of youngsters being terrorized,  but as the killings continue, the old gang returns to set things straight. Dewey Riley (David Arquette) still lives in town, but after being stabbed nine times, resulting in permanent nerve damage and a funny little limp, he’s retired from the force. His ex-wife Gale Weathers (Courteney Cox) is off in New York hosting a TV morning show and still chasing fame. And Sidney Prescott (Neve Campbell) is married and raising a child with no intentions of ever returning to Woodsboro. 

Shot in 3.4K, images are consistently clean. Edges have nice definition and you can see textural details like the fine lines in Dewey’s corduroy jacket. While closeups have plenty of detail, letting you easily appreciate the differences between the smooth, near-poreless complexions of the “new” cast and the fine lines around Sidney’s eyes and the weathering and wrinkles in Dewey’s face, images were never tack sharp like some digital productions and felt more film-like.

The HDR isn’t overdone but does provide a realistic image, with some extra brightness when needed for the occasional bright lights. Outdoor scenes look terrific with loads of natural lighting, and you can clearly see the difference between the exterior lighting and the stark fluorescent overheads inside a hospital or the bright sunlight pouring in through sheer blinds. Blacks are nice and clean and blood-reds are appropriately saturated.

Horror movies are often the perfect playground for creative and immersive Dolby Atmos mixes, and while this Scream’s Dolby TrueHD mix isn’t over the top, it gets the job done and has some nice moments that certainly add to the tension, such as jump-scare music and ill-timed phones ringing. Outdoor scenes have plenty of atmospherics in the form of whistling wind, traffic sounds, and birds chirping, with the interior of the hospital sounding completely different with people chattering, phones ringing, the buzz of lights, and elevators dinging. During one scene, rolling thunder travels through the room overhead, and notice the clear sound of Dewey’s spent brass falling on the ground, bouncing and rolling.

Deep bass is called on to punctuate certain moments, such as adding sonic weight to door locks clunking into place or the deep throaty engine roar of a big muscle car firing up, and then the throbbing rumble and growl of it idling. Gunshots also have nice sharp dynamics. 

Scream/Stab is a “meta-slasher whodunit” and it kept me guessing up till the end about who was behind the mask. While there’s enough new here to keep noobs entertained, you should at least watch the original as it is still the freshest and most original of the bunch and lays the foundation for this Scream. And with a Scream 6 already greenlit, now is a great time to revisit Woodsboro. Just remember . . . trust no one! 

Probably the most experienced writer on custom installation in the industry, John Sciacca is co-owner of Custom Theater & Audio in Murrells Inlet, South Carolina, & is known for his writing for such publications as Residential Systems and Sound & Vision. Follow him on Twitter at @SciaccaTweets and at johnsciacca.com.

PICTURE | Closeups have plenty of detail, letting you easily appreciate the differences between the smooth complexions of the “new” cast and the fine lines around Sidney’s eyes and the weathering and wrinkles in Deputy Dewey’s face

SOUND | While the Dolby TrueHD Atmos mix isn’t over the top, it gets the job done and has some nice moments that certainly add to the tension, such as jump-scare music and ill-timed phones ringing

Generic selectors
Exact matches only
Search in title
Search in content
Post Type Selectors

© 2023 Cineluxe LLC

Review: Scream (1996)

Scream (1996)

review | Scream (1996)

related reviews

Sign up for our monthly newsletter
to stay up to date on Cineluxe

Wes Craven shocked the slasher genre back to life with this meta-heavy horror classic

by John Sciacca
October 26, 2021

The teen-slasher genre had been stagnating in the ‘90s when along came Wes Craven of Freddy Krueger and A Nightmare on Elm Street fame to totally upend and breathe new life into the genre with Scream. It’s hard to believe Scream is celebrating its 25th anniversary but the good news is that Paramount has given it a 4K HDR transfer. 

 While Scream certainly has its share of gore, it never feels like the focus of the story. Right from the get-go, it lets you know this was going to be a different horror-movie experience, and in the opening 12 minutes, it unsettled the audience by killing off its biggest star, Drew Barrymore. Of course, Craven just aped what Alfred Hitchcock famously did with Janet Leigh in Psycho. 

The script was also unique in just how self-aware the characters were. They not only love horror movies but the cast frequently name-checks other horror films. They also lay out—and then the film plays with—the classic slasher-film “rules” and clichés about who survives. And as the ultimate wink-nod to horror fans, Craven himself has a cameo as a striped-sweater-wearing school janitor who happens to be named Fred. Red herrings and misdirection abound throughout, and after the shock of Barrymore’s death, viewers knew anyone could be killed—all of which told moviegoers they were in for a new and different ride, and the traditional rules of the genre were out the window.

It was interesting to re-watch Scream knowing the outcome, much like people will go back through The Sixth Sense to see if M. Night Shyamalan made any continuity mistakes. Here, when you know what—and who—to look for, there are some subtle clues that tell you who the killer is that give the film another layer of enjoyment.

Originally shot on 35mm film, this transfer is from a 4K digital intermediate, and the clarity and detail show. Of course, as with many film-to-4K transfers, there are some moments of softness or uneven focus but these are likely in the original and the movie still has that organic film look. What I really appreciate with a well-done transfer is just how clean images look. Fortunately, much of Scream—particularly the opening—is filmed up close, letting you really see the texture and detail in the actors’ faces—the smooth skin and fine whiskers, Sidney’s freckles, and the detail in Barrymore’s sweater and the fine strands of her hair.  

Don’t expect a lot of eye-popping HDR but the grade definitely enhances the natural look of the film with nice deep blacks and shadow detail. Also, much of the second half is shot at night, and things like bright car headlights, police lights, fluorescent lighting, lightning strikes, and bright white T-shirts get some added pop, as do subtle things like the glints of highlights from droplets of sweat or tears on actors’ cheeks. I also noticed the subtle sparkle and flecks of silver in the killer’s black outfit. Nothing really pushes the bounds of HDR’s wider color gamut but we get some really nice and vibrant yellows, oranges, and reds in a sunset, along with the rich blue of Sidney’s denim, and of course the intense reds of blood.

The Kaleidescape download features a 5.1-channel DTS-HD Master Audio mix. The dialogue is always presented nice and clear in the center channel. Sounds like ringing phones, ticking clocks, and creaking floors happen way off screen, expanding the width of your listening area. My processor’s DTS: Neural X upmixer was also able to extract some nice ambience from the mix. Small sounds like clocks and wind chimes, echoes, wind whistling through an HVAC register, or PA announcements fill the room and immerse you in what’s happening on screen. Parts of the score are also “lifted” up to the ceiling speakers to add a nice height layer. 

The mix isn’t super dynamic but it can deliver some strong, even tactile, bass, such as during a big lightning storm in the opening. And while there isn’t a lot of gunfire, the few instances are recorded loud and sharp and are definitely standout moments.  

While some of the dialogue between the “teenagers” (Campbell and McGowen were 23, and Ulrich and Matthew Lillard were both 26) is a little cringey, most of Scream holds up surprisingly well and it’s still a lot of fun to watch. The timing is also a bit serendipitous as rewatching this new transfer of the 1996 original will help set the mood for the Scream reboot  coming in January 2022, which brings back the big surviving three—Sidney, Gale Weathers, and Deputy Dewey—from the original film.

Probably the most experienced writer on custom installation in the industry, John Sciacca is co-owner of Custom Theater & Audio in Murrells Inlet, South Carolina, & is known for his writing for such publications as Residential Systems and Sound & Vision. Follow him on Twitter at @SciaccaTweets and at johnsciacca.com.

PICTURE | As with many 35mm-film-to-4K transfers, there are some moments of softness or uneven focus, but these are likely in the original film, and Scream still has that organic film look.

SOUND | The 5.1-channel DTS-HD Master Audio mix is certainly adequate for telling the story, and the most important element—the dialogue—is always presented nice and clear in the center channel

Generic selectors
Exact matches only
Search in title
Search in content
Post Type Selectors

© 2023 Cineluxe LLC

Scroll to top

sign up for our newsletter

receive a monthly recap of everything that’s new on Cineluxe